Toward tailoring the specificity of the S1 pocket of subtilisin B. lentus: chemical modification of mutant enzymes as a strategy for removing specificity limitations

In both protein chemistry studies and organic synthesis applications, it is desirable to have available a toolbox of inexpensive proteases with high selectivity and diverse substrate preferences. Toward this goal, we have generated a series of chemically modified mutant enzymes (CMMs) of subtilisin B. lentus (SBL) possessing expanded S(1) pocket specificity. Wild-type SBL shows a marked preference for substrates with large hydrophobic P(1) residues, such as the large Phe P(1) residue of the standard suc-AAPF-pNA substrate. To confer more universal P(1) specificity on S(1), a strategy of chemical modification in combination with site-directed mutagenesis was applied. For example, WT-SBL does not readily accept small uncharged P(1) residues such as the -CH(3) side chain of alanine. Accordingly, with a view to creating a S(1) pocket that would be of reduced volume providing a better fit for small P(1) side chains, a large cyclohexyl group was introduced by the CMM approach at position S166C with the aim of partially filling up the S(1) pocket. The S166C-S-CH(2)-c-C(6)H(11) CMM thus created showed a 2-fold improvement in k(cat)/K(M) with the suc-AAPA-pNA substrate and a 51-fold improvement in suc-AAPA-pNA/suc-AAPF-pNA selectivity relative to WT-SBL. Furthermore, WT-SBL does not readily accept positively or negatively charged P(1) residues. Therefore, to improve SBL's specificity toward positively and negatively charged P(1) residues, we applied the CMM methodology to introduce complementary negatively and positively charged groups, respectively, at position S166C in S(1). A series of mono-, di-, and trinegatively charged CMMs were generated and all showed improved k(cat)/K(M)s with the positively charged P(1) residue containing substrate, suc-AAPR-pNA. Furthermore, virtually arithmetic improvements in k(cat)/K(M) were exhibited with increasing number of negative charges on the S166C-R side chain. These increases culminated in a 9-fold improvement in k(cat)/K(M) for the suc-AAPR-pNA substrate and a 61-fold improvement in suc-AAPR-pNA/suc-AAPF-pNA selectivity compared to WT-SBL for the trinegatively charged S166C-S-CH(2)CH(2)C(COO(-))(3) CMM. Conversely, the positively charged S166C-S-CH(2)CH(2)NH(3)(+) CMM generated showed a 19-fold improvement in k(cat)/K(M) for the suc-AAPE-pNA substrate and a 54-fold improvement in suc-AAPE-pNA/suc-AAPF-pNA selectivity relative to WT-SBL.